Explore this topic: Housing rights and landlord requests
A landlord who refuses your emotional support animal (ESA) without a lawful reason may be discriminating against you, but in 2026 where you live decides how well you can enforce that. The federal Fair Housing Act still requires reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities, and many state and city laws name ESAs outright. What changed is that HUD, the federal housing agency, said in May 2026 that it would stop pursuing complaints about untrained ESAs. So your strongest protections now often come from your state or local law and from the courts, and the way you ask and document your request matters more than ever.
TL;DR
- The Fair Housing Act itself has not been amended. HUD’s May 22, 2026 memo changes how the agency handles complaints about untrained ESAs, not the text of the law.
- State and city laws in places such as California, Florida, Massachusetts, Maryland and New York City still address ESAs as reasonable accommodations.
- Landlords generally may not charge pet fees for an assistance animal or demand your diagnosis, but they may deny a request for real safety, damage or hardship reasons, or when the documentation is not credible.
- Keep everything in writing. Evidence you gather on day one is what proves discrimination later.
- Complaints to HUD must be filed within one year of the last discriminatory act. State agencies have their own deadlines.
Table of Contents
- What housing discrimination means for an ESA owner
- What HUD changed in May 2026, and what it did not
- Where state and local law still protect ESAs
- When a landlord can lawfully say no
- Fees, deposits and what a landlord can ask you
- How to make a request that holds up
- How to prove housing discrimination
- Filing a complaint and what remedies exist
- Perspective
- Where to keep learning
- FAQ
- Sources
What housing discrimination means for an ESA owner
The Fair Housing Act (FHA) is the federal law that bans discrimination in housing. Disability is one of its protected categories. In practice, that means a housing provider must make a “reasonable accommodation”: a change to a rule or policy that gives a person with a disability equal opportunity to use and enjoy their home. Idaho Legal Aid Services explains that disability means a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, and that a no-pet property must allow an assistive animal when it is needed.
An ESA is an animal that eases the symptoms of a mental or physical condition through companionship. Unlike a service dog, it is not trained to perform specific tasks. That difference is exactly what the 2026 policy shift turns on, so it helps to understand it. Our guide to ESA vs. service dog differences covers the distinction in detail, and what the terms assistance animal and ESA mean explains why the labels matter in a lease dispute.
Discrimination can show up as:
- A flat refusal because “we don’t allow pets.”
- A pet deposit, monthly pet rent or extra insurance charged only because of your animal.
- Breed or weight limits applied to your ESA without any look at your situation.
- Demands for medical records, your diagnosis or a specific form.
- Eviction threats, harassment or retaliation after you made a request.
- Ignoring your request so long that it amounts to a denial.
This is not rare. In 2024 there were 17,986 disability-based fair housing complaints, 52.61% of all Fair Housing Act complaints nationwide, making disability the most common basis for a complaint.
What HUD changed in May 2026, and what it did not
On May 22, 2026, HUD’s Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity (FHEO) issued an internal enforcement memorandum telling its staff how to assess animal-related accommodation requests. According to a summary from the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, the memo cancels HUD’s earlier ESA guidance from 2013 and 2020 and applies the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) idea of an animal individually trained to do work or tasks. Under that approach, comfort alone would not count.
Two points keep this from being the end of the story:
- The statute is the same. The same summary notes that Congress did not act and that no court has ruled ESAs out of housing protections. The memo guides HUD’s own investigators and is not a new law.
- HUD is not the only route. Many states have their own fair housing laws and agencies, and a private lawsuit goes to a court, which is not bound by an agency memo.
What this means for you: a federal HUD complaint about an untrained ESA is now harder to win, so your state or local fair housing agency, a legal aid office or a fair housing attorney may be the better first stop. We track the shift on our page about ESA housing rights in 2026.
Where state and local law still protect ESAs
Because housing law is layered, the same request can get different answers in different places. These official sources show how.
| Place | What the official source says |
|---|---|
| California | Housing providers must allow an ESA for a tenant with a disability-related need as a reasonable accommodation unless an exception applies, and must either permit it or promptly engage in an interactive process. |
| Florida | Florida Statutes §760.27 (2025) makes it unlawful to discriminate against a person with a disability-related need for an ESA, and bars extra compensation for the animal. |
| Massachusetts | Fair housing laws cover most housing, including private housing and condominiums, while owner-occupied two-family houses can refuse assistance animals. |
| Maryland | A blanket rejection without individualized inquiry will very often violate the law, and a provider must make a good-faith attempt at an interactive process. |
| New York City | Providers, including shelters and temporary or supportive housing, must permit ESAs as a reasonable accommodation unless it would cause undue hardship. |
The “interactive process” in the California and Maryland guidance is simply a back-and-forth conversation. If the landlord has concerns, they must talk with you about alternatives instead of saying no and ending the discussion.
If your state is not listed, search for your state’s civil rights or human rights commission and read its guidance on assistance animals. Rules, exceptions and deadlines differ, and some small owner-occupied buildings are exempt in some places.
When a landlord can lawfully say no
Not every denial is discrimination. Knowing the lawful reasons helps you tell the difference and prepare a stronger request.
A provider may deny or revoke an accommodation in situations like these:
- Direct threat. Under Florida’s statute, a denial is allowed if the animal poses a direct threat to safety, health or property that another accommodation cannot reduce.
- No established disability-related need. Massachusetts guidance lists this, along with direct threat and fundamental alteration or undue burden. It adds that the resident must get a chance to provide more information before a denial for inadequate documentation.
- Undue hardship. Maryland’s guidance says undue financial or administrative hardship can make an accommodation unreasonable.
- Fraudulent paperwork or damage. Florida Legal Services lists improper, fake or fraudulent documentation, damage caused by the animal, and other tenants being threatened or attacked as situations where eviction can follow.
Notice what is missing from that list: “we have a no-pets policy” and “your dog is over our weight limit.” Those are the rules an accommodation exists to adjust.
Fees, deposits and what a landlord can ask you
This is where tenants most often hit unlawful demands, and where a clear understanding saves money.
Fees. Idaho Legal Aid says providers cannot ask a tenant who needs an assistive animal to pay a pet deposit or fee, cannot require special training for the animal, and cannot inquire about the nature or severity of the disability. New York City’s fact sheet says a provider cannot preemptively charge extra security deposits or pet fees, or require added renter’s insurance, but may require payment for actual damage or excessive wear and tear.
Paperwork. In New York City, a provider may ask for confirmation from a treatment provider that you have a disability and the animal helps treat it, but cannot require your specific diagnosis, a particular form or dated documentation. Florida’s law likewise bars requests for information that discloses your diagnosis or severity, or medical records, and bars requiring a notarized statement. It also says an ESA registration, ID card, patch or certificate bought on the Internet is not by itself enough to establish a disability or need.
That last point trips up a lot of people. A Colorado State University study cited by Florida Legal Services found that 44.7% of people mistakenly believed a certificate or ID can lawfully be required for an ESA or service dog. The law does not require one, and paying for a registry does not create a right. What carries weight is a statement from a licensed professional who actually treats you.
Rules that can still apply. You can be asked to keep the animal leashed or harnessed in common areas, and certain species are barred under New York City’s Public Health Code. You are also liable for damage the animal causes. Florida’s statute adds that providers may require proof of licensing and vaccination compliance.
How to make a request that holds up
A well-built request makes it hard for a landlord to refuse and gives you evidence if they do.
- Ask in writing. Email or a dated letter beats a hallway conversation. Say you have a disability and are requesting a reasonable accommodation to keep an assistance animal. You do not need to name your diagnosis.
- Include support from a licensed professional. A letter from a licensed clinician who treats you, confirming your disability and the way the animal helps, is the document landlords legitimately look for. Be careful with any site that sells instant certificates, because those are the papers that provoke fraud accusations.
- Keep the details in order. As with any housing arrangement that involves pets or care, it helps to put the details in writing: what was agreed, who is responsible for what, and when.
- Do not volunteer medical records. Answer what the landlord is allowed to ask and no more.
- Save everything. Keep emails, texts, voicemail, your lease, the listing, and notes of calls with dates.
- Follow up if you hear nothing. A very long silence can function as a denial, so note the date you asked and the date you followed up.
If you live in military housing, different channels apply, and our guide to ESAs in military housing walks through the options. Students in dorms should read their school’s disability services process too, since colleges often run their own accommodation request systems.
How to prove housing discrimination
Proof comes down to a clear story with documents behind it. HUD’s housing discrimination claim form asks you to summarize what happened and why you believe it was discrimination, including being denied a disability-related reasonable accommodation, and to describe your evidence and any witnesses. You can submit it online or by mail to the regional FHEO office.
Strong evidence usually includes:
- Your written request and the date you sent it.
- The landlord’s reply, or proof that none came.
- The clinician’s letter you provided.
- Receipts or statements showing a pet fee, deposit or rent increase imposed because of the animal.
- Texts or emails with comments about your animal or disability.
- Names of neighbors or staff who saw or heard relevant events.
- A timeline showing any eviction notice or harassment that followed your request.
What real cases look like
Federal enforcement actions show the patterns. In United States v. Christensen, filed in March 2020, the Department of Justice alleged that a landlord violated the FHA by seeking to evict a tenant for keeping an ESA, denying the accommodation request, and retaliating. In United States v. Smolnik, the complaint alleged that the owners of a 15-lot mobile home park required a pet deposit for an assistance animal and harassed the complainants. The September 2021 consent order required $40,000 to the HUD complainants, fair housing training and injunctive relief.
Those cases predate the 2026 memo, so treat them as examples of what discrimination looks like, not as a forecast of how HUD will handle an untrained-ESA complaint today.
Filing a complaint and what remedies exist
HUD’s process, described on its FHEO intake and investigation page, works like this:
- You file an allegation with FHEO within one year of the last date of the alleged discrimination.
- FHEO investigates or refers the matter, and tries conciliation, which is a negotiated settlement.
- If it finds a violation, HUD or the Department of Justice may take legal action.
- At a hearing before an administrative law judge, HUD attorneys represent the complainant at no cost. Relief can include actual damages, injunctive and equitable relief, attorney’s fees and civil penalties.
Given the May 2026 memo, expect that a federal complaint about an untrained ESA may be treated differently from before. That is why a parallel filing with your state or local civil rights agency is worth considering, since their rules and deadlines are separate. Legal aid organizations can also help: Florida Legal Services notes that fair housing project attorneys may draft formal accommodation letters on behalf of tenants whose requests were denied or ignored. If you are facing eviction, talk to a housing attorney or a legal aid office in your area quickly, because eviction deadlines are short.
Can you sue? Yes, a private lawsuit is a separate option that does not depend on HUD, but whether it succeeds depends on your state’s law, your documentation and the facts. A fair housing attorney is the right person to assess that.
Perspective
We built Supportpet because the gap between what the law says and what renters believe it says is where people get hurt. Some are turned away by landlords who misread the rules. Others are sold certificates and registrations that carry no legal weight and then get accused of fraud.
The 2026 HUD memo makes clear information more important, not less. Our view is that the safest path is to understand your own state’s rules, ask in writing, and rely on a recommendation from a licensed clinician who knows you, never on an ID card or an online registry.
That is why we keep our content free and independent. We do not sell documents or registrations, and we explain the federal, state and local picture in plain language so you can decide your next step with accurate facts.
Erik
Where to keep learning
If you are a renter, student or pet owner trying to make sense of all this, we publish plain-language guides on ESA letters, housing rights, travel and scams, free to read and not tied to selling any certificate. Start with our ESA housing rights guide for the 2026 changes, or browse the Supportpet home page for the full set.

If a hotel stay is part of your plans, our note on why travelers may still pay pet fees explains how travel rules differ from housing rules.
FAQ
Can apartments legally deny an ESA?
Sometimes, but not simply because of a no-pet policy. Providers can deny when the animal is a direct threat, would cause undue hardship, or when there is no established disability-related need. Maryland’s guidance says a blanket rejection without individualized inquiry will very often violate the law, and the provider should try an interactive process first.
Does the 2026 HUD memo mean landlords can ignore ESAs everywhere?
No. The memo directs HUD staff on how to evaluate complaints and does not rewrite the Fair Housing Act. State and local laws, such as those in California and New York City, still address ESAs. Check your own state’s agency for the rules that apply to you.
Can a landlord charge a pet fee for my ESA?
Generally not for an assistance animal. Idaho Legal Aid says providers cannot require a pet deposit or fee, and New York City’s rules allow charges only for actual damage or excessive wear and tear. Local rules vary, so confirm yours.
How long do I have to file a housing discrimination complaint?
A complaint to HUD must be filed within one year of the last date of the alleged discrimination. State and local agencies and courts set their own deadlines, which can differ, so do not wait.
Is an online ESA registration or certificate enough?
No. Florida’s statute says an Internet registration, ID card, patch or certificate is not by itself sufficient to establish a disability or need. A statement from a licensed professional who treats you carries real weight.
Sources
- Housing Discrimination | Idaho Legal Aid Services
- HUD FHEO Enforcement Guidance, May 22, 2026
- An Enforcement Agency That Won’t Enforce: HUD’s Policy Reversal on Emotional Support Animals | DREDF
- Emotional Support Animals (ESAs) | Florida Legal Services
- Chapter 760 Section 27, 2025 Florida Statutes
- Assistance animals in housing | Mass.gov
- Guidance: Disability Accommodations in Housing | Maryland Commission on Civil Rights
- Emotional Support Animals in Housing FAQ | NYC Commission on Human Rights
- Emotional Support Animals and Fair Housing Law FAQ | California Civil Rights Department
- DI-7927 Housing Discrimination Claim Form | HUD
- Complaint, United States v. Christensen | U.S. Department of Justice
- United States v. Smolnik | U.S. Department of Justice
- Learn About FHEO’s Process to Report and Investigate | HUD
- Pets and Home Care
Recommended
- Renters: How HUD’s 2026 ESA Guidance Changes Your Housing Rights
- Don’t Lose Your ESA: Prove ESA Housing Rights After HUD’s 2026 Memo
- No Pets Policy for Renters: ESA Rights Survive HUD’s 2026 Shift
- HUD’s May 22, 2026 ESA Guidance: 4 Steps for Tenants and Landlords